Doctrinal and Policy Perspectives on the Law: The Shifting Methodological Landscape of Contemporary Legal Scholarship
‘Policy work’ is becoming ever more prominent in contemporary practices of legal scholarship - mainly due to the specific ways in which modern state law has co-evolved with the administrative state. Policy formation (as well as implementation and review) is now integral to all aspects of governance. As a result, an increasing amount of positive law becomes instrumental to specific policy objectives: most new law takes the form of targeted regulatory interventions. This forces most academic legal research to combine doctrinal and policy considerations to at least some extent. Sorting out the relationship between (and the interplay of) the two becomes a crucial methodological challenge for legal scholars today. This is a considerable challenge because we are surprisingly short on suitable theoretical frameworks that would relate the doctrinal and the policy perspective to one another in plausible and instructive ways. In this presentation, I offer an analysis of the complementary roles of doctrinal and policy research using three (epistemological) features as points of orientation: interpretivism, internalism, and normative orientation. I also explore what we can learn about the character of academic legal study (and academic disciplinarity more broadly) from reflecting on the complementary roles of doctrinal and policy work.
This will be a hybrid event (Teams). Please click the link below to join online:
https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/3877886632116839?p=ZPF0ahslX18NBFHdPF
- Speaker
- Venue
- Add to Calendar