- WOC1.16 - Changes in spatial wage differences in the UK and the implications for healthcare funding in the period since the global financial crisis
The project aimed to investigate changes in the patterns of regional wage differences in the UK in the period since the global financial crisis. Regional differences in wages are an important element of the formula which underpin the distribution of monies to Central Commissioning Groups (CCGs) in the NHS in England and to fund local authority activities.
Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings (ASHE) and Labour Force Survey (LFS) data were used to detail changes in spatial wage differences since 2008. The project explored the drivers of these differences and the consequences of the observed changes for the distribution of funding to CCGs.
Outcome and Translation
Regional differences in wages are an important element of the formulae which underpin the distribution of monies to CCGs in the NHS in England and the funding of local authority activities. Understanding changes in the underlying patterns of spatial wage differences and how this impacts on funding streams are of interest to both the Government who allocate the funds and to those who receive the funding.
- WOC1.18 - The effects of pay restraint on NHS Scotland staff groups within the Agenda for Change pay system
A period of pay restraint had been in operation within NHS Scotland since 2011. Following a previous multi-year settlement that took effect in 2008/9, 2009/10 and 2010/11, there was no general pay uplift for two years (2011/12 and 2012/13), followed by a further 5 years where a 1% pay uplift was awarded with additional flat rate increases for lower spinal points. This research analysed and assessed the effect of this pay restraint on NHS Scotland staff on Agenda for Change Pay Scales within the wider economic situation in Scotland. The research was undertaken within a very short timescale and focused on the collation and where necessary the adaption of existing evidence.
Outcome and Translation
This research was commissioned by the Scottish Terms and Conditions Committee (STAC) the body which negotiates terms and conditions issues relevant to NHS Scotland. The findings will support submissions to the NHS Pay Review Body.
External collaborators: Skåtun, J.D. (Department of Economics, University of Aberdeen)
Skåtun, D., Leckcivilize, A. and Skåtun, J.D. (2017) The effects of pay restraint on NHS Scotland staff groups within the Agenda for Change pay system. Final Report to the Scottish Terms and Conditions Committee (STAC).
- WOC2.19 - Health economic evaluation of the Lothian high demand service
Reducing ‘avoidable unscheduled attendances and admissions to hospital’ is recognized as one of the eight key areas of improvement NHS Scotland’s 'Shifting the Balance of Care Improvement Framework'. The Improvement Framework identifies a variety of approaches to achieve shifts in the balance of care, two elements of which include the identification of patients who are most at risk of hospital admission, and the development of patient care plans. Such care plans are built on the understanding that a substantial proportion of individuals who arrive in A&E Departments, or have other forms of unplanned hospital admissions, do not require, or want, acute hospital care, suggesting that it may be possible to reduce acute care costs by providing alternative approaches to acute care. Furthermore, a small number of individuals account for a large proportion of such hospital admissions (often termed “high demand” patients). In 2014, NHS Lothian initiated a service to identify and manage “high demand” patients, by implementing a system of Anticipatory Care Plans (ACPs) amongst those at high risk of future hospital admission. We conducted a comparative before-and-after study of hospital admissions, emergency department visits, length of hospital stay and hospital costs, to estimate the overall service impact.
Outcome and Translation
The results suggest that introduction of ACPs led to a statistically significant reduction in the number of unplanned hospital admissions and emergency department (ED) visits. There was also an associated reduction in length of hospital stay for unplanned admissions, and lower hospital costs for ED visits and inpatient care. These outcomes suggest that ACPs are a promising intervention to consider if hospitals wish to reduce the number of unplanned hospital admissions. The findings have been highlighted in the Chief Medical Officer for Scotlands’ Annual Report in 2019.
External collaborators: R. Steel (NHS Lothian)
McNamee, P., Leckcivilize, A., Cooper, C. and Steel, R. (2018) 'Can Anticipatory Care Plans (ACPs) reduce unplanned hospital admissions?', 6th Annual Research Symposium: Evidence for Integration, COSLA Conference Centre, Edinburgh, 24 April 2018.
- WOC1.13 - Impact of working conditions on absenteeism in the public healthcare sector: explore the role of job satisfaction and mental illness on absenteeism
HERU Postdoctoral Fellowship
This project investigated the role of job satisfaction and mental illness on work absenteeism in the public healthcare sector.
Using secondary data-sources, the project explored sickness absenteeism variations within the public sector. Distinctively, the public sector was segmented into vocational and non-vocational sectors, assuming that vocation leads to differing degrees of job attachment and hence alter sickness leave.
Outcome and Translation
Increased absenteeism is costly for NHS employers and may compromise the quality of care to patients. It is important to understand the role of non-pecuniary organisational factors, as well as health-related factors as determinants of work absenteeism. Results provide more insights on the role of organisational and health-related factors on work absenteeism in the public healthcare sector.
HERU researchers involved in this research project: Ourega-Zoé Ejebu and Diane Skåtun
Ejebu, O. and Skåtun, D. (2018) 'Vocation, mental illness and the absenteeism decision', Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 60(12), 1136-1142.
Ejebu, O. and Skåtun, D. (2015) 'Mental illness and sickness absenteeism among workers: evidence from the BHPS', Nordic Health Economists' Study Group (NHESG), Uppsala University, Sweden, 19 - 21 August 2015.
Ejebu, O. and Skåtun, D. (2017) 'Cyclicality in work absenteeism across employment sector: an exploratory study of the role of vocation in public health sector using UK HLS', Scottish Economic Society Annual Conference 2017, Mercure Perth Hotel, Perth, 24 April 2017.
- WOC2.20 - Insecure employment and mental health: one pathway in the productivity puzzle
We will link the Annual Survey of Hours and Earning with the Business Structure Database to form a large matched employer-employee dataset. Using this dataset, we aim to advance the understanding of insecure employment and productivity by identifying characteristics of the employers which could potentially benefit from reducing insecure employment. This project complements our ongoing research which values the benefits to employees, in terms of health-related quality of life, of limiting exposure to insecure employment.
Outcome and Translation
Our analysis indicates a causal negative relationship between insecure employment and labour productivity. The results predict that for each 1% reduction in insecure employment, the growth rate of labour productivity will increase by 0.7%. However, these effects are only observed within industries in the bottom half of the economy-wide labour productivity distribution - i.e. industries with relatively low productivity. Previously, we established a causal effect between insecure employment and mental health. The findings from these two pieces of research combine to indicate that by reducing insecure employment, employers can increase productivity and provide a health benefit to employees.
HERU researchers involved in this research project: Daniel Kopasker
External Collaborators: C. Montagne (University of Aberdeen Business School)
Kopasker, D. and Montagna, C. (2019) Insecure employment and mental health: one pathway in the productivity puzzle, Small Project Report, Sheffield PIN - Productivity Insights Network, University of Sheffield.
Kopasker, D. (2020) 'Good work and mental health in the post-COVID era', Productivity Insights Network Webinar [Online], 16 July 2020.
- WOC2.16 - MUNROS
Health Care Reform: the iMpact on practice, oUtcomes and costs of New roles for health pROfeSsionals
This project is undertaking a systematic evaluation of the impact of these ‘new professional roles’ on practice, outcomes and costs in a range of different healthcare settings within European Union and associate countries. It details the nature, scope and contribution of the new professional roles, evaluates their impact on clinical practice and outcomes, and identifies their scope to improve the integration of care. It conducts economic evaluation to identify the cost-effectiveness of the new professional roles, identifies optimal models for delivery of healthcare and the consequences of these for management of human resources and workforce planning. Study design is cross-sectional and multi-level. A mixed methods approach combines analysis of routinely collected data and primary data generated through interviews and questionnaires to health professionals, managers and patients. Data analysis employs multi-level modelling techniques.
Outcome and Translation
The project demonstrated that across the nine countries and three conditions studied there is variation in the extent to which the wider health care team is involved in patient care. Where the extended team is involved patients are satisfied, clinical outcomes are similar to more traditional care and there are potential cost savings. The results have been disseminated through a variety of approaches (e.g. invited talks, contributions to complementary projects, conference presentations, briefing papers) and are informing policy development at the highest level, at the OECD, EC and individual countries.
The MUNROS Project conference was held on the 6th February 2017.
HERU researchers involved in this research project: Robert Elliott, Hanne Bruhn, Daniel Kopasker and Sebastian Heidenreich
External collaborators: C Bond (Centre of Academic Primary Care, University of Aberdeen); A de Bont (Erasmus University); R Busse (Technische Universität Berlin); M Ruggeri (Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore); M Mijal (University of Warsaw); H Svobodová (Charles University Prague); G Okem (Economic Policy Research Foundation of Turkey); JE Askildsen (Uni Research Norway) and M Sutton (University of Manchester).
for further details visit Munros website
Tsiachristas, A., Wallenburg, I., Bond, C. M., Elliot, R. F., Busse, R., van Exel, J., Rutten-van Molken, M. P. and de Bont, A. (2015) 'Costs and effects of new professional roles: evidence from a literature review', Health Policy, 119(9), 1176-1187.
Bond, C., Bruhn, H., de Bont, A., van Exel, J., Busse, R., Sutton, M., Elliott, R.F. and the Munros team (2016) 'The iMpact on practice, oUtcomes and costs of New roles for health pROfeSsionals' [protocol], BMJ Open, 6, e010511.
de Bont, A., van Exel, J., Coretti, S., Okem, Z. G., Janssen, M., Hope, K. L., Ludwicki, T., Zander, B., Zvonickova, M., Bond, C., Wallenburg, I. and and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.). (2016) 'Reconfiguring health workforce: a case-based comparative study explaining the increasingly diverse professional roles in Europe', BMC Health Services Research, 16(1), 637.
Maier, C.B., Köppen, J., Busse, R. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.) (2018) 'Task shifting between physicians and nurses in acute care hospitals: cross-sectional study in nine countries', Human Resources for Health, 16(1), 24.
Köppen, J., Maier, C.B., Busse, R., Bond, C., Elliott, R.F., Bruhn, H., McLaggan, D., Zvonickova, M., Hodyc, D., Svobodová, H., Sutton, M., Gibson, J., McBride, A., Zander, B., Coretti, S., Ruggeri, M., van Exel, J., de Bont, A., Luyendjk, M., Askildsen, J.E., Islam, M.K., Opsahl, J., Sobczak, A., Dykowska, G., Winter, M., Ostrowska, S., Mijal, M., Basihos, S., Dogan, M. and Güldem Ökem, Z. (2018) 'What are the motivating and hindering factors for health professionals to undertake new roles in hospitals? A study among physicians, nurses and managers looking at breast cancer and acute myocardial infarction care in nine countries', Health Policy, 122(10), 1118-1125.
Maier, C.B., Batenburg, R., Birch, S., Zander, B., Elliott, R.F. and Busse, R. (2018) 'Health workforce planning: which countries include Nurse Practitioners and Physician Assistants and to what effect?', Health Policy, 122(10), 1085-1092.
Ruggeri, M., Drago, C., Moramarco, V., Coretti, S., Köppen, J., Islam, K., Gibson, J., Busse, R., van Exel, J., Sutton, M., Askildsen, J.E., Bond, C. and Elliott, R.F. (2018) 'New professional roles and patient satisfaction: evidence from a European survey along three clinical pathways', Health Policy, 122(10), 1078-1084.
Birch, S., Gibson, J., McBride, A. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.) (2020) 'Opportunities for, and implications of, skill mix changes in health care pathways: Pay, productivity and practice variations in a needs-based planning framework', Social Science and Medicine, 250(April), 112863.
Kopasker, D., Islam, M. K., Gibson, J., Lau, Y.-S., Sutton, M., Askildsen, J. E., Bond, C. and Elliott, R.F. (2020) 'Skill mix and patient outcomes: a multi-country analysis of heart disease and breast cancer patients', Health Policy, 124(10), 1074-1082.
Bond, C. (2013) ‘MUNROS project: overview’, Stakeholder Workshop, Karolinum of the Charles University, Ovocny Trh. 3, Prague, 26th September 2013.
de Bont, A. and MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.) (2014) 'Changing skill mix within teams delivering integrated health services', EU Chronic Care Summit, Brussels, 3rd April 2014.
Archibald, D., Bond, C. and Elliott, R.F. (2014) 'Identifying the drivers of new professional roles in European health systems', Health Economics in the Age of Longevity: a Joint iHEA & ECHE Congress, Trinity College, Dublin, 13-16 July 2014.
Tsiachristas, A., Wallenburg, I., de Bont, A., Archibald, D., Bond, C. and Elliott, R.F. (2014) ‘Costs and effects of health service redesign: evidence from a literature review’ Health Economics in the Age of Longevity: a Joint iHEA & ECHE Congress, Trinity College, Dublin, 13-16 July 2014.
Elliott, R.F. (2014) 'MUNROS: challenging terrain for economists', Workshop to mark 60th birthday of Jan Erik Askildsen, Department of Economics, University of Bergen, 14 November 2014.
de Bont, A., Wallenburg, I. and MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.)(2014) 'On health care reform: the iMpact on practice, oUtcomes and costs of New roles for health pROfeSsionals’', Working Group on Health Workforce, Brussels, 24 November 2014.
de Bont, A., Wallenburg, I. and MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.) (2014) 'On health care reform: the iMpact on practice, oUtcomes and costs of New roles for health pROfeSsionals', Zorgplatform, Utrecht, 3rd December 2014.
Elliott, R.F. (2014) 'MUNROS project - the iMpact on practice, oUtcomes and costs of New roles for health pROfeSsionals', Joint Action Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting, Conference on improving planning methodologies and data across Europe, Rome, Italy, 4 December 2014.
de Bont, A. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.), (2015) 'Invited presentation about the MUNROS project for EC Directorate-General for Health Healthcare Systems Unit - Workforce Team', Summit on Innovation for Active and Healthy Ageing, Brussels, Belgium, 9-10 March 2015.
de Bont, A. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and. Bond, C.) (2015) 'New professional roles in Europe', International Sociological Association (ISA) RC52, Professions Bonds and Boundaries: Visioning a Globalising, Managed and Inclusive Professionalism, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Milan, Italy, 19-21 March 2015.
Bond, C. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.), (2015) 'MUNROS overview presentation', 15th International Health Workforce Conference, Royal College of Physicians, London, England, 12-13 May 2015.
Ökem, G. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.), (2015) 'New professional roles in care pathways in diabetes II, breast cancer and acute myocardial infection in some selected European countries and Turkey: initial results of MUNROS project', 9th International Congress on Quality in Healthcare, Accreditation and Patient Safety, Antalya, Turkey, 13-16 May 2016.
Bond, C. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.) (2015) 'The iMpact on practice, oUtcomes and costs of New ROles for health care professionalS: results from the MUNROS study', 44th Annual Scientific Meeting of Society for Academic Primary Care (SAPC), Evidence and Innovation in Primary Care, University of Oxford, Oxford, England, 8-10 July 2015.
Elliot, R.F. (2015) 'The impact of the new professional roles on clinical practice and the organisation of care: emerging results. Organised session', International Health Economics Association (iHEA) 11th World Congress, Milan, Italy, 12-15 July 2015.
Zvoníčková, M., Svobodová, H., Vlček, F. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.), (2015) 'Expanding role of paramedical staff in the Czech Republic and in selected European countries', Way to Modern Nursing XVII, Motol Teaching Hospital, Prague, Czech Republic, 17 September 2015.
de Bont, A., Bond, C. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.), (2015) 'The MUNROS project: exploring the introduction of new professions and professional roles', Joint meeting EU Chief Medical Officers and Chief Nursing Officers, Luxemburg, 12 October 2015.
de Bont, A. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.), (2015) 'The impact on practice of new roles for health professionals: MUNROS study', 20th World Organization of National Colleges, Academies and Academic Associations of General Practitioners/Family Physicians (WONCA) Europe Conference, Istanbul, Turkey, 22-25 October 2015.
Elliot, R.F. and Bond, C. (2016) 'The MUNROS Study: changing health care roles in breast cancer care', Scottish Cancer Trials Breast Group Meeting, Hilton Hotel, Edinburgh Airport, Edinburgh, 28 January 2016.
Sutton, M. and the MUNROS Team (led by Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C.), (2016) 'Towards a more efficient use of health human resources OECD', Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Workshop, OECD Conference Centre, Paris, France, 27 June 2016.
Elliot, R.F., Bond, C. and Sutton, M. (2016) 'New roles for health professionals: findings from the MUNROS project', European Union Directorate Knowledge Hour, Presentation to invited members of Directorate General Research and Employment, Brussels, Belgium, 6 September 2016.
Elliott, R.F. (2017) 'MUNROS project overview', MUNROS Project Conference, Royal College of Surgeons, Edinburgh, 6 February 2017.
Heidenreich, S., Skåtun, D., Ryan, M., Van Exel, J., Elliott, R.F. and Bond, C. (2017) 'Patients’ preferences for specialised health professionals in follow-up care: a cross-country and cross-disease comparison', 5th International Choice Modelling Conference, Cape Town, South Africa, 3-5 April 2017.
Kopasker, D., Islam, K., Gibson, J., Lau, Y.-S., Sutton, M., Askildsen, J.E., Bond, C. and Elliott, R.F. (2019) 'Skill mix and patient outcomes: a multi-country analysis of heart disease and breast cancer patients', Health Economists' Study Group (HESG) Winter 2019 Meeting, Centre for Health Economics (CHE), University of York, York, England, 7-9 January 2019.
Kopasker, D., Islam, K., Gibson, J., Lau, Y.-S., Sutton, M., Askildsen, J.E., Bond, C. and Elliott, R.F. (2019) 'Skill mix and patient outcomes: a multi-country analysis of heart disease and breast cancer patients', Scottish Health Economics. Showcasing Health Economics in Scotland: Research of International Excellence That Addresses Policy Priorities in Scotland and Beyond, Discovery Point, Dundee, 3 October 2019.
- WOC1.14 - PhD: A mixed-methods study of career decision making in Foundation Programme doctors
Medical workforce training and planning are at the forefront of policy and practice discussions. Difficulties in recruiting and retaining trainees threaten the reliable delivery of care and have massive long-term implications for the NHS in Scotland. This project will employ a discrete choice experiment (DCE) to explore the factors influencing medical trainee career-decision making to better understand the flow of trainees through the training pathway. It forms part of a broader PhD research project led by Medical Education entitled ‘A mixed-methods study of career-decision making in Foundation Programme doctors’.
Outcome and Translation
The research undertaken within this PhD thesis provides important information to workforce planners and to the NHS on quantifying the factors that medical trainees find important in their training stages and thus provides the service with a better understanding the flow of trainees through the training pathway.
PhD Student: Gillian Scanlan
Supervisors: Diane Skåtun (HERU); J. Cleland (Medical Education, University of Aberdeen); P. Johnston, K. Walker (NHS Education for Scotland).
Scanlan, G.M., Cleland, J., Johnston, P., Walker, K., Krucien, N. and Skåtun, D. (2018) 'What factors are critical to attracting NHS foundation doctors into specialty or core training? A discrete choice experiment', BMJ Open, 8(3), e019911.
Scanlan, G., Johnston, P., Walker, K., Skåtun, D. and Cleland, J. (2020) 'Today's doctors: what do men and women value in a training post?', Medical Education, 54(5), 408-418.
Scanlan, G.M., Cleland, J., Johnston, P., Walker, K., Krucien, N. and Skåtun, D. (2018) 'What factors are critical to attracting NHS foundation doctors into specialty or core training? A discrete choice experiment', Scottish Medical Education Conference, Edinburgh International Conference Centre, Edinburgh, 26-27 April 2018.
- WOC2.18 - PhD: Enhancing quality in social care through economic analysis
Population ageing has motivated policy makers around the world to focus on how best to organise health and social care services to meet an anticipated growing demand on services. Two popular initiatives are re-ablement and telecare. Re-ablement is an approach within homecare that enables older individuals with social care needs to improve their functional performance and live independently. Telecare, on the other hand, involves use of devices to monitor individuals’ health and safety, and provide response when needed. Evidence from the existing literature suggests that there are few economic studies investigating the effects of re-ablement and telecare, especially in Scotland. The generalisability of the existing studies is also questionable given that most of them have small sample sizes and high attrition rates. To this end, we undertook economic analyses of linked administrative health and social care data in Scotland. Our estimation strategy controlled for potential selectivity bias, endogeneity of key variables and unobserved heterogeneity in tandem.
Outcome and Translation
The findings from this thesis informed the factors associated with better outcomes; helped identify the groups of people that are most likely to benefit from the interventions; and showed the relative importance of telecare in improving outcomes. More specifically, it was shown that some of forms of telecare (community alarms) were associated with a reduced probability of admission to hospital in the emergency department, whilst other types of telecare had the opposite effect. Further, those living in remote areas, and those living with multiple conditions, were also more likely to be admitted as emergency cases. Finally, some form of telecare (community alarms) were associated with reduced length of hospital stay amongst some patients (those with physical disability).
PhD Student: Kevin Momanyi
Momanyi, K. (2019) 'Enhancing quality in social care through economic analysis', PhD Thesis, HERU, University of Aberdeen.
Momanyi, K., McNamee, P. and Skåtun, D. (2016) 'Enhancing quality in social care through economic analysis', PhD Health and Social Care Symposium, Farr Institute, NHS National Services Scotland, Edinburgh, 22 June 2016.
Momanyi, K., McNamee, P. and Skåtun, D. (2016) 'Enhancing quality in social care through economic analysis', Institute of Applied Health Sciences (IAHS) Postgraduate Research Student Symposium, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, 24 June 2016.
Momanyi, K. and McNamee, P. (2017) 'Reducing unplanned hospitalisation in Scotland: is it time to consider telecare?', School of Medicine, Medical Sciences and Nutrition Postgraduate Research Conference, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, 29 November 2017.
- WOC1.17 - Risk preferences and GP migration
Emigration by doctors is of increasing concern given the high training costs and the shortage of doctors in the UK. It is crucial to increase our understanding of emigration decisions. This paper focused on the role of risk preferences. Emigration is fundamentally a risky decision and evidence suggests that risk seeking individuals are more likely to migrate. However, it is unclear whether this can be generalised to doctors. It could be argued that there is less financial risk associated with emigration and some destination countries have lower rather than higher levels of risk associated with career and clinical care. The aim of this paper was to compare risk preferences of GPs who qualified in the UK and emigrated to Australia with those who are currently practising in Scotland. We used data from Australia's national longitudinal survey of doctors (MABEL) which included 275 GPs who qualified in the UK and data from a survey of 295 Scottish GPs. Risk preferences were elicited for financial risks, career and professional risks and clinical risks on a scale from 1 to 5.
Outcome and Translation
This research showed that UK trained GPs who migrated to Australia were more risk averse than GPs in Scotland. This suggests that outward migration of GPs may be reduced by reducing risk and uncertainty within the UK NHS.
HERU researchers involved in this research project: Marjon van der Pol and Alastair Irvine
External collaborators: A. Scott (University of Melbourne), O. Bezannier (Université Paris-Est Créteil)
Pol, M. van der, Scott, A. and Irvine, A. (2019) 'The migration of UK trained GPs to Australia: does risk attitude matter?', Health Policy, 123(11), 1093-1099.
Pol, M. van der, Scott, A., Irvine, A. and Bezannier, O. (2018) 'Risk preferences and GP migration', Health Economists' Study Group (HESG) Winter 2018 Meeting, City Health Economics Centre, City, University of London, London, England, 10-12 January 2018.
Pol, M. van der, Scott, A., Irvine, A. and Bezannier, O. (2018) 'Risk preferences and GP migration', 12th European Conference on Health Economics (EuHEA), Maastricht, The Netherlands, 11-14 July 2018.
- WOC1.12 - Understanding push-pull factors in medical careers decision making
Existing research indicates factors such as the perceived benefits of particular specialities, wish for quality of life, and demographic factors, such as gender, are influential. However, we do not know the most important ‘push-pull’ careers-decision making factors for the current generation of UK medical students and trainees. What drives medical students and trainees away from a place or a speciality? What draws them to a new location or a different speciality? To what extent are specific factors important at different transitions?
This project used anonymous, online surveys to gather contemporary UK data on these issues from medical trainees and students. A Discrete Choice Experiment was used to identify the most important push-pull factors in medical careers-decision making.
Outcome and Translation
Our results suggest organisations could focus on improving working conditions for trainees to a minimum standard, promote linked training positions for medical couples, and provide access to career support for non-medical partners. Alternatively, organisations might provide monetary incentives to trainees for accepting posts that do not meet their preferred conditions. Medical students were also found to value good working conditions more than they value geographical location.
External collaborators: J Cleland (University of Aberdeen), C Rees (University of Dundee), K Mattick (University of Exeter) and P Johnston (NHS Education for Scotland (NES))
Cleland, J., Johnston, P., Mattick, K., Rees, C., Skåtun, D.,Watson, V. and Krucien, N. (2013) Understanding push-pull factors in medical careers decision making. Final report, NHS Education for Scotland.
Cleland, J., Johnston, P., Watson, V., Krucien, N. and Skatun, D. (2016) 'What do UK doctors in training value in a post? A discrete choice experiment', Medical Education, 50(2), 189-202.
Skåtun, D., Watson, V., Krucien, N., Johnston, P. and Cleland, J. (2016) 'Junior doctors training: is it really location, location, location?', HERU Policy Brief, September 2016, University of Aberdeen.
Cleland, J.A., Johnston, P., Watson, V., Krucien, N. and Skåtun, D. (2017) 'What do UK medical students value most in their careers? A discrete choice experiment', Medical Education, 51(8), 839-851.
Cleland, J., Skåtun, D., Watson, V., Krucien, N. and Johnston, P. (2014) 'Novel use of a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) in medical education', General Practice and Primary Care (NADEGS) National Conference, Carnoustie, 23-24 January 2014.
- WOC2.15 - Using discrete choice experiments to investigate optimal skill mix
With increasing demands on health services policy is looking at alternative ways of providing healthcare. Examples include extending the role of pharmacists and nurses in the management of common ailments, promoting self-care of symptoms indicative of self-limiting illness, and extending the roles of specialist nurses and physician associates in some clinical areas. We use discrete choice experiments (DCEs) to investigate preferences in the management of different illnesses.
Outcome and Translation
A general finding is that, whilst individuals often prefer to see a doctor or consultant, improvements in other aspects of care (reduced waiting time, continuity of care, longer consultation times) can compensate them for not seeing their preferred health worker.
External collaborators: Terry Porteous, Christine Bond, Alison Elliott, Phil Hannaford and Peter Murchie (Academic Primary Care, University of Aberdeen)
Porteous, T., Ryan, M., Bond, C. and Hannaford, P. (2006) 'Preferences for self-care or consulting a health professional in minor illness: a discrete choice experiment', British Journal of General Practice, 56, 911-917.
Ryan, M. and Porteous, T. Preferences for self-care or consulting a health professional in minor illness. HERU Briefing Paper, July 2007, University of Aberdeen.
Rennie, L. Patient preferences for managing different types of symptoms - self-care or health professional advice? A discrete choice experiment. Thesis presented for the degree of Bachelor of Medical Sciences (BScMedSci). University of Aberdeen, May 2010.
Rennie, L., Porteous, T. and Ryan, M. (2012) 'Preferences for managing symptoms of differing severity: a discrete choice experiment', Value in Health, 15(8), 1069-1076.
Murchie, P., Norwood, P. F., Pietrucin-Materek, M., Porteous, T., Hannaford, P. C. and Ryan, M. (2016) 'Determining cancer survivors' preferences to inform new models of follow-up care', British Journal of Cancer, 115, 1495-1503.
Norwood, P., Ryan, M., Murchie, P., Pietrucin-Materek, M., Porteous, T. and Hannaford, P. (2017) 'Survivors of cancer seeking care continuity and lengthier appointments', HERU Policy Brief, March 2017, University of Aberdeen.
Porteous, T. and Ryan, M. (2006) 'Factors influencing the choice between self-care and health professional advice in minor illness: a discrete choice experiment' Health Sciences Research and Pharmacy Practice Conference, University of Bath, April 2006.
Porteous, T. and Ryan, M. (2006) 'Factors influencing the choice between self-care and health professional advice in minor illness: a discrete choice experiment', Social Dimensions of Health Institute Conference, University of Dundee, May 2006.
McAteer, A., Elliott, A.M., Yi, D., Watson, V. and Ryan, M. (2009) 'Investigation preferences for symptom management using Discrete Choice Experiment', [poster] Society for Academic Primary Care Conference, St Andrews, July 2009.
Rennie, L., Porteous, T. and Ryan, M. (2011) 'Preferences for managing different types of symptoms – self care or health professional advice?', Health Services and Pharmacy Practice Research Conference, Norwich, May 2011.
Pietrucin-Materek, M., Murchie, P., Porteous, T. and Hannaford, P. C. (2012) 'What do cancer patients want from their follow up? A discrete choice experiment (DCE) study to investigate preferences for cancer follow-up amongst people with breast, prostate, colorectal cancer and cutaneous melanoma', [poster] Society for Academic Primary Care (SAPC) Celebrating Difference Conference, Glasgow, October 2012.
- WOC1.15 - MMF2: Updating the staff Market Forces Factor
The staff Market Forces Factor (sMFF) is the mechanism in England by which both funding allocated to commissioners of healthcare and the tariff that providers of healthcare can charge are adjusted to reflect the unavoidable costs of commissioning/providing health care across different geographical locations. The current sMFF is based on estimates of spatial wage differentials using 2007–2009 Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings (ASHE) data. The focus of this project will be on providing a new updated Staff MFF index based on the latest data available from ASHE. This ensures funding and pricing reflects the current labour market conditions faced by commissioners and providers of healthcare.
Outcome and Translation
The focus of this project was to provide a new updated Staff MFF index based on the latest data available from ASHE. This ensures funding and pricing reflects the current labour market conditions faced by commissioners and providers of healthcare.
External collaborators: Alex McConnachie (University of Glasgow) and Nigel Rice (University of York)
Skåtun, D., Elliott, R.F., Ejebu, O., McConnachie, A., Rice, N. and Wetherall, K. (2017) The staff market forces factor component of the resource allocation weighted capitation formula: new estimates 2013-2015, Aberdeen: HERU.
Elliott, R.F., Kopasker, D. and Skåtun, D. (2020) 'Public-sector resource allocation since the financial crisis', International Journal of Manpower, [Epub ahead of print].
Skåtun, D. (2018) 'NHS funding allocations: generating the Staff Market Forces Factor', UK Data Service Secure Lab User Workshop, London, England, 2 October 2018.