The term dryland is a collective noun for all types of arid
region. Drylands cover over one third of the present global land
area, which rises to nearly 50% if the dry sub-humid category is
included. Such regions are highly variable in climate. The term
'desert' is a botanical description, and is avoided because it is
inadequately defined.
There are many schemes to classify aridity of climate
zones, each with different end-uses such as food production, water-supply,
geomorphology. In essence they all consider moisture availability,
and look at the balance between supply (precipitation) and losses
(evaporation and transpiration from plants).
Arid zones are those where evapotranspiration exceeds
precipitation. It is important to keep in mind that amount of rainfall
alone is not the absolute control. For example, in the Lake Eyre
basin of central Australia, annual precipitation may be up to 300mm,
but losses commonly exceed 3000mm of rainfall equivalent (Kotwicki
& Allan, 1998).
Floodplain processes,
Huab River, Namibia
Some schemes try to take into account retention of
moisture in soils, since this affects how rapidly rainfall is converted
into runoff. Some try and account for seasonality of precipitation,
since the effect of rainfall spread evenly through the year is clearly
going to be different from the same rainfall arriving in just two
months of the year. Yet others take into account the mean summer
or winter temperatures, or the difference between them, since this
controls the variation in evapo-transpiration throughout the year.
In practice, nearly all the schemes end up classifying
the same parts of the planet in essentially the same way. All have
subdivisions into semi-arid, arid, and hyper-arid, based on a scale
of increasing aridity. Some schemes include a slightly less arid
zone called dry sub-humid.
The widely applied United Nations classification
(UNEP, 1992) uses an aridity index, AI, where AI = P/PET. P is annual
precipitation. PET is potential evapotranspiration, which is calculated
from meteorological data. In this scheme, the subdivisions are:
AI
Category
<
0.05
Hyper-arid
0.05
- 0.2
Arid
0.2
- 0.5
Semi-arid
0.5
- 0.65
Dry-subhumid
As a rough guide, the subdivisions of aridity can be equated approximately
to mean annual precipitation. When this is done, it is crucial to
bear in mind that rainfall alone is not the sole control on aridity,
and to remember that averaging rainfall is misleading, because in
arid zones there may be many years when rainfall is zero. A commonly
used conversion is that of Grove (1977):
Rainfall
< 25 mm
Hyper-arid
25 - 200
mm
Arid
200 - 500
mm
Semi-arid
When studying the rock record, clearly we have no meteorological
data available, and have to use proxies instead. We cannot directly
estimate either precipitation or evapotranspiration, all we can
see is the effect of the balance between them.
Drylands are created where climatic, topographic or oceanographic
factors prevent moisture-bearing weather systems reaching that zone.
Global atmospheric patterns
The sub-tropical regions are dominated by dry high-pressure air.
Solar heating of the atmosphere is greatest at the Equator, making
air rise, which in turn causes it to cool, producing water condensation
and creating a cloudy central zone with equatorial belts of rain.
The air spreads out at high altitude towards the poles and descends
in the subtropics at around 30° north and south. The now-dry
air warms adiabatically as it descends, creating a consistently
warm and dry region. The air returns near the surface to the tropics,
as the Trade Winds, picking up moisture on the way. This stable
tropical-to-subtropical circulation is called a Hadley Cell.
At higher latitudes, air circulation is controlled more by the
rotation of the Earth, and by the temperature contrast between the
Equator (most solar radiation) and the poles (least solar radiation).
At high altitudes, air generally moves west to east (jet streams),
and warm moist air is carried towards the poles. Cold and dry polar
air moves back again at lower altitudes, interacting as it goes
with the polewards moving warm air. The outcome is a complex pattern
of mobile weather systems (cyclones and anticyclones) displaying
considerable vertical and lateral instability. In general, this
high-latitude pattern is not conducive to creating aridity.
This global circulation pattern means that, in general, the subtropics
are warm arid zones where precipitation is scarce and irregular.
These drylands are surrounded by narrow semi-arid regions. The main
relief in such regions comes from seasonal monsoons penetrating
the high-pressure cells from the Equator.
The diffuse boundary between the equatorial Hadley cells and the
more energetic high-latitude weather systems is called the Inter-Tropical
Convergence Zone (ITCZ). This is the zone of maximum aridity. The
position of the ITCZ moves up to about 20° south during the
northern-hemisphere winter, and north again during the summer, because
the tilt of the Earth's axis means the zone receiving maximum solar
radiation itself moves progressively south then north, respectively,
of the Equator during the year. Therefore the zone of maximum aridity
moves south and north with the seasons.
Continentality
Distance from marine or other sources of moisture encourages aridity.
So drylands occur near the centres of large landmasses. The Trade
Winds blow from east to west, so drylands commonly extend westwards
to the coasts because the winds lose their moisture in travelling
across large continents. This effect produces small arid zones surrounded
by broad semi-arid regions.
Topography
Mountain ranges create rain shadows and prevent moisture-laden air
from entering some regions by forcing the air to rise, which makes
it cool and causes the water to condense and precipitate. On the
lee side, the descending air is warmed and dried adiabatically.
The Great Divide of eastern Australia cuts off the interior from
the Trade Winds. The Andes shelter the Argentinian drylands.
Cold ocean currents
Cold ocean currents flowing from the Poles to the Equator affect
the western coastal margins of South America, southern Africa and
Australia. These currents reinforce cause low rates of sea-surface
evaporation, low precipitation (often as fog and dew due to the
lower temperatures), and a low temperature range, reinforcing other
climatic factors. For example, the lack of rainfall in the Namib
Desert is due to the cold Benguela current impacting the west margin
and the failure of easterly rain-bearing winds to penetrate across
the African continent.
Fig.
1 shows the present-day distribution of drylands around the
planet. North Africa and Arabia are clearly dominated by the global
subtropical high pressure belt. Central Asia is dominated by the
continentality effect. North American drylands are the combined
product of topography (Sierra Nevada and Rocky Mountains) and continentality.
South America is dominated by the combined effect of cold ocean
current on the west coast, and the elevated topography of the Andes.
An overview of the geomorphology of each of the main drylands on
the planet today can be found in Oberlander (1994).
Drylands currently occupy more than one-third of the global land
surface. Using the UNEP (1992) definitions, the proportions are:
Hyper-arid
7.5
%
Arid
12.1
%
Semi-arid
17.7
%
Dry-subhumid
9.9
%
Total
47.2
%
Annual temperature regimes vary considerably, though a wide temperature
range is common to all. Temperature affects the seasonal availability
of moisture, and the form in which precipitation arrives (snow in
high latitudes). It also affects vegetation types. A common subdivision
is (Meigs, 1952):
%
of
arid lands
Mean
temperature °C
Coldest
month
Warmest
month
Hot
43
10-30
>30
Mild
winter
18
10-20
10-30
Cool
winter
15
0-10
10-30
Cold
winter
24
<0
10-30
Boundaries between regions are diffuse, and change with time. On
this scheme, examples of hot drylands would be Arabia, central Sahara,
central Australia; mild drylands are the Kalahari, southern Sahara,
Mexico, northern Australia; cool drylands are northern Sahara, Atacama,
and southern California; cold drylands are Gobi, China, Canadian
Prairies, and higher parts of the SW USA such as the Colorado Plateau.
The climate of modern drylands is known to have changed over short
time-spans. At the scale of decades (101
years), fluctuations occur because of short-term instability in
global circulation patterns, and ocean-controlled phenomena such
as El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) in the Pacific, and
its Atlantic equivalent. These produce extended periods (5-10 years)
of drought in some locations while causing extended wet periods
elsewhere, and will produce a pulsed sedimentological signature.
At the century time-scale (102 years),
the southern margin of the Sahara has migrated southwards in the
Sahel region (LeHouerou, 1968), though it is unclear if these changes
were triggered by human influence such as over-grazing.
At the thousand-year scale (103 years),
major changes in climate are well documented which are clearly not
triggered by human influence. For example, there seems to have been
a global increase in aridity at about 4.5 to 3.5 ka BP which coincides
with the socio-economic collapse of several cultures (Petit-Maire
& Guo, 1998).
We know the Pleistocene glaciations had a marked effect on many
drylands, producing changes at the 104-105
year scale which were seen as wetting and drying phases. During
the glacials, aridity increased, as moisture was locked up in the
ice, and winds were stronger, which increased evaporation rates.
In the inter-glacials, there were periods much wetter than the present.
Such variation is well documented even in areas far away from glaciated
regions, such as in central Australia (Nanson et al., 1992).
But the effects of the glacial periods on depositional environments
were not perhaps as one might expect. During the glacials, temperatures
were depressed, which reduced evaporation rates. So, even though
rainfall was still restricted, lakes became permanent or larger,
and rivers flowed more persistently; an effect which has been clearly
documented in Lake Eyre (Nanson et al., 1998). This is a phenomenon
that would have been relevant even at times when global glaciation
was negligible, such as in the Triassic, and again demonstrates
that precipitation alone is not the dominant control on drylands.
When considering possible climate changes in the Triassic, it should
be noted that computer-based climate modelling suggests that Pangaea
was unusually sensitive to orbital (Milankovitch) forcing effects
on climate (Crowley, 1994; Veevers, 1994), though it may be southern
Pangaea was more sensitive than northern parts. We might therefore
expect to see variations with typical Milankovitch periodicities,
currently averaging at about 21ka, 41ka, and 100ka (Williams et
al., 1993 p.81-85).
At the much longer time scale of 106-107
years (geological periods), major climate shifts took place as continental
drift moved drylands into more humid climatic settings, and changes
occurred in global atmospheric and oceanic circulation patterns.
What is not clear is how the transition from dryland to humid-land
would have affected sedimentation. Is there a gradual change, or
does the system cross a threshold and rapidly switch into a new
behaviour? Geomorphological research over the last three decades
would suggest the latter is more likely (e.g. Schumm & Parker,
1974; Begin & Schumm, 1984).
Great care must be exercised when interpreting climate change events
from the sedimentological record to use as local or regional correlation
markers.
Dryland rivers sediments are not reliable at recording small to
medium amounts of climate change. Periods of extreme aridity leave
little record: rivers are inactive, the only clue may come from
aeolian reworking but this is possible even in wet periods. The
preserved record is dominated by deposits from periods of wetter
and cooler climate. Even when dryland sedimentary systems do respond
to change, the response may not yield an unequivocal record: for
example, lakes may form and grow larger, and rivers may have more
persistent flow, either because the climate is wetter or because
the average temperature has dropped.
Because sedimentary processes in drylands are irregular, as a general
rule dryland rivers are out of equilibrium with the local conditions.
This contrasts with perennial rivers, in humid climates, which respond
quickly to local change. If the sediments of dryland rivers are
not correctly recording the ambient conditions, it is highly unlikely
they will correctly record changes in the conditions unless the
magnitude of change is large and maintained for a long time.
Changes to dryland climate do not have to be large to elicit a
dramatic and complex response, if the change forces the river system
to cross a geomorphic threshold (Bull, 1979). Indeed, the whole
concept of geomorphic thresholds was developed from study of dryland
rivers (e.g. Schumm & Hadley, 1957; Patton & Schumm, 1981).
The difficulty for those interpreting the rock record is that it
is easily possible to have changes occur which are large enough
to produce a river response, yet which can be localised in geographic
extent (e.g. restricted to one valley system). For example, a difference
in elevation (so changing average temperature) between two valleys
may be sufficient to inhibit in one the effects of rainfall reduction
seen in the other.
Climate changes occur with a wide variety of periodicities, the
rock record is simply the additive response to these different superimposed
frequencies. Which will be dominant and so leave the sedimentological
record?
Average sedimentation rates for dryland rivers are relatively low,
and decrease with increasing aridity. Furthermore, large magnitude
but infrequent flood events dominate the sedimentary processes,
so the rock record is going to be biased to these rare events. It
is highly likely, therefore, that short-period changes in climate
will be inaccurately represented, and may leave no record at all.
The signatures of change we are most likely to discern are going
to be the large magnitude and long-period events. These are not
good for correlation because the transition between phases is long,
leaving a low-resolution record (where do you pick the change to
have occurred?).
It is the cumulative effect of these problems that leads to disagreement
between workers on the recognition of "wetting and drying"
cycles in red-bed successions, a phenomenon well know to those working
on the Rotliegend Group of the southern North Sea. For the same
succession, one worker sees drying-up cycles, another sees them
as wetting-up.
It is abundantly clear, despite the above warnings, that drylands
have been dominant features of the planet surface in the geological
past. We can tell this for particular time periods, and some geographical
locations, because of the distinctive sedimentary record left behind.
For example, the region currently occupied by the Colorado Plateau,
in SW USA, was a persistent dryland from the late Permian to the
Middle Jurassic, as reflected by the substantial thickness of aeolian
sandstones (e.g. the Cedar Mesa, Wingate, Navajo, and Entrada sandstones
- see review by Blakey et al., 1988). There can be no doubt that
the fluvial sediments intercalated between these aeolian units were
the deposits of dryland rivers.
Modern plate reconstructions allow us to understand the causes
of aridity in the past. For example, the Colorado Plateau was in
a subtropical position for much of the Mesozoic era. The time of
the Pangaean supercontinent provided ample opportunity for the continentality
effect to produce huge dryland areas (Veevers, 1994). In other cases,
we can deduce the presence of major topographic barriers.
As an example, it is possible to make some general predictions
about aridity in the Triassic simply by looking at plate reconstructions.
The Lower Triassic of NW Europe is characterised by a variety of
aeolian, fluvial and other continental lithofacies characterstic
of drylands.
At this time, the Pangaea super-continent had been well established
for some time, and was about to break up (Klein et al., 1994). Much
of Pangaea experienced an arid climate because of its situation
around the sub-tropics (global circulation patterns), and the large
size of the land mass (continentality).
In the Early Triassic, the Variscan-Hercynian mountains created
an orographic barrier between the ocean (Tethys) and NW Europe (Fig.
2), and would have enhanced the aridity expected because of
the sub-tropical location. As the Triassic progressed, however,
these mountains were eroded down, and the Tethyan Ocean encroached
further west into Europe, bringing marine flooding to southern Britain
in the Rhaetian. Both these effects would have ameliorated the climate.
It is widely accepted that monsoons were a regular feature of the
Triassic (Crowley, 1994). This seasonality may have allowed moisture-bearing
systems to penetrate into the otherwise arid regions, much as the
summer monsoons bring irregular rainfall to central Australia today
(Kotwicki & Allan, 1998). Comparisons with the countries surrounding
the present-day Pacific suggest that superimposed on the annual
variations in the weather systems of the Triassic would be longer-period
fluctuations such as the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO)
phenomenon (Kotwicki & Allan, 1998).
We must be careful about such predictions of the past, because
many factors are non-uniformitarian. Prediction of Triassic dryland
locations based on the known driving forces for Recent drylands
must take into account unusual planetary events occurring around
the Permian-Triassic boundary (see summary in Veevers et al., 1994).
For example, coal-forming conditions during the Pennsylvanian in
Euramerica, and Permian in the Gondwanaland province, were terminated
by global warming that accompanied excessive venting of CO2
into the atmosphere during the eruption of the Permian/Triassic
(~250 Ma) Siberian Traps and other volcanics. The resulting gap
in coal deposition lasted through the Early and Middle Triassic
until the excessive CO2 was finally resorbed
by the crust (Veevers, 1994).
What we still struggle with is interpreting the subtleties of the
climate variation in past times. The alternation between aeolian
and fluvial and lacustrine litofacies, such as seen in the Lower
Permian Rotliegend Group of NW Europe, implies significant and repeated
climate fluctuation (e.g. see George & Berry, 1997). But we
still have some way to go before we fully understand the driving
forces, and the lithological successions produced.
BLAKEY, R.C., PETERSON, F. & KOCUREK, G. 1988.
Synthesis of late Palaeozoic and Mesozoic eolian deposits of the
Western Interior of the United States. Sedimentary Geology, 56,
3-126.
BEGIN, Z.B. & SCHUMM, S.A. 1984. Gradational thresholds
and landform singularity - significance for Quaternary studies.
Quaternary Research, 21, 267-274.
BULL, W.B. 1979. The threshold of critical power in
streams. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 90, 453-464.
CROWLEY, T.J. 1994. Pangean climates. In: KLEIN, G.D.
& BEACHAMP, B. (eds) Pangea: paleoclimate, tectonics, and sedimentation
during accretion, zenith, and breakup of a supercontinent. Geological
Society of America special paper 288, Boulder, Colorado, 25-39.
GEORGE, G.T. & BERRY, J.K. 1997. Permian (Upper
Rotliegend) synsedimentary tectonics, basin development and palaeogeography
of the southern North Sea. In: ZIEGLER, K., TURNER, P. & DAINES,
S.R. (eds) Petroleum geology of the southern North Sea: future potential.
Geological Society special publication 123, London, 31-61.
GROVE, A.T. 1977. The geography of semi-arid lands.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B-278,
457-475.
KOTWICKI, V. & ALLAN, R. 1998. La Niña
de Australia - contemporary and palaeo-hydrology of Lake Eyre. Palaeogeography,
Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 144, 265-280.
LEHOUEROU, H.N. 1968. La desertification du Sahara
septentrional et des steppes limitrophes (Libye, Tunisi, Algerie).
UNESCO, Paris.
MEIGS, P. 1952. Arid and semiarid climatic types of
the world. In: Proceedings, eighth general assembly and seventeenth
international congress, International Geographic Union. Washington,
135-138.
NANSON, G.C., CALLEN, R.A. & PRICE, D.M. 1998.
Hydroclimatic interpretation of Quaternary shorelines on south Australian
playas. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 144,
281-305.
NANSON, G.C., PRICE, D.M. & SHORT, S.A. 1992.
Wetting and drying of Australia over the past 300 ka. Geology, 20,
791-794.
OBERLANDER, T.M. 1994. Global deserts: a geomorphic
comparison. In: ABRAHAMS, A.D. & PARSONS, A.J. (eds) Geomorphology
of desert environments. Chapman & Hall, London, 13-35.
PATTON, P.C. & SCHUMM, S.A. 1981. Ephemeral stream
processes: implications for studies of Quaternary valley fills.
Quaternary Research, 15, 24-43.
PETIT-MAIRE, N. & GUO, Z.T. 1998. Mid-Holocene
climatic change and Man in the present-day Sahara desert. In: ALSHARHAN,
A.S., GLENNIE, K.W., WHITTLE, G.L. & KENDALL, C.G.St.C. (eds)
Quaternary deserts and climatic change. A.A.Balkema, Rotterdam,
351-356.
SCHUMM, S.A. & HADLEY, R.F. 1957. Arroyos and
the semiarid cycle of erosion. American Journal of Science, 255,
161-174.
SCHUMM, S.A. & PARKER, R.S. 1974. Implications
of complex response of drainage systems for Quaternary alluvial
stratigraphy. Nature, 243, 99-100.
SCOTESE, C.R. 1994. Early Triassic palaeogeographic
map. In: KLEIN, G.D. & BEACHAMP, B. (eds) Pangea: paleoclimate,
tectonics, and sedimentation during accretion, zenith, and breakup
of a supercontinent. Geological Society of America special paper
288, Boulder, Colorado.
UNEP. 1992. World atlas of desertification. Edward
Arnold, Sevenoaks, UK.
VEEVERS, J.J. 1994. Pangea: evolution of a supercontinent
and its consequences for Earth's paleoclimate and sedimentary environments.
In: KLEIN, G.D. & BEACHAMP, B. (eds) Pangea: paleoclimate, tectonics,
and sedimentation during accretion, zenith, and breakup of a supercontinent.
Geological Society of America special paper 288, Boulder, Colorado,
13-23.
WILLIAMS, M.A.J., DUNKERLEY, D.L., DE DECKKER, P.,
KERSHAW, A.P. & CHAPPELL, J. 1993. Quaternary environments.
2nd edition. Arnold, London.