What does it mean to be a human being created in the image of God that has a disability? One aspect of human disability is the way in which it is socially constructed. In other words, society is designed in a way that does not consider the effects of biological disability resulting in the disabling of the functionality of certain people within society. In a similar way, theology that does not consider the experience of disability can disable the spirituality of people with that experience. Many of the problems associated with “disabling theology” have been addressed by disability theologians often resulting in an abandoning of traditional theology in a way creates God in a human image that reflects disabled experiences. This study seeks to address the question of the creation of humanity in the image of God by beginning with traditional theology and through empirical research into the Christian experience of people with disabilities within a church context dialogue on the ways that the traditional theology fails to consider and account for disability. The expected outcome of this dialogue is a revised theology of humanity created in the image of God that considers and accounts for disability. The revised theological understanding then becomes the underpinning for a revised Christian praxis that realizes the place of people with disability in the community of believers.